IFEX Asia brief: July, August, September 2024

July 2024. Student protests, post-election reforms, impunity, and journalists on strike in Asia-Pacific. Protests turned deadly in Bangladesh, a list of concrete measures to uphold free speech in India, media killings in Pakistan, and journalists declared a strike in Australia.

August 2024. South Asia in focus: Youth-led uprising, women’s rights crisis, and internet disruption. It has been a tumultuous August for South Asia: Student protests forced the resignation of Bangladesh’s prime minister, the Taliban marked their third year in power amid the continuing oppression of Afghan women, Pakistan’s internet encountered disruptions, and Sri Lanka authorities have doubled down on enforcing security laws ahead of a crucial presidential election.

September 2024. Spotlighting access to information in Asia and the first Pacific media freedom index. How did IFEX members mark the International Day for Universal Access to Information? New reports showed the decline of media and academic freedom in Hong Kong, the Taliban issued another repressive directive for news outlets, and the Pacific Media Freedom Index was unveiled for the first time.

Posted in east asia, media | Tagged | Leave a comment

Community actions offer hope and alternative

Published by Bayan Metro Manila

Community pantries and clean-up drives offer concrete solutions that directly alleviate the hardships of our people, while disproving the claim of the government that only repressive lockdown models are effective in containing COVID-19 cases.

The establishment of community pantries in recent days highlighted the slow and inadequate arrival of aid amid worsening hunger and poverty after the government renewed harsh quarantine restrictions in the NCR Plus. Meanwhile, several community-driven clean-up activities were organized in Baseco, Tumana, and Arboretum (QC) in contrast to the costly, ugly, and wasteful government-initiated dumping of crushed Dolomite in Manila Bay.

These local actions underscored the crucial role of the community in addressing the public health and environment crisis.

After a year of relying on strict lockdown measures, we saw how they failed in preventing the spread of the coronavirus aside from causing widespread economic and social disruptions. We were told there’s no other option but to endure the world’s longest lockdown.

But the success of the community pantries and the effort of residents to organize clean-up drives and urban gardens in their areas reminded us that the militarized lockdown approach is counterproductive and that the stubborn refusal to reject this preferred solution is causing unnecessary suffering.

Instead of simply herding people inside their homes, authorities should have enjoined them to mobilize community efforts in battling the pandemic and other social woes.

The problem with the militarized and military-led response of the government is that it treated the social crisis as a mere peace and order issue. Hence, the imposition of police measures such as curfews, lockdowns, security checkpoints, and intensified surveillance.

The lockdown approach stifled citizen-led initiatives and undermined the application of the Bayanihan model in tackling the problems linked to the pandemic.

If the government is overwhelmed in handling the crisis, it should learn to trust the community frontliners and consider them as partners in overcoming the pandemic. However, the Rodrigo Duterte government had failed to embrace this solution because it used the pandemic to consolidate power through the use of fear and strong arm tactics.

Posted in Bayan, health, places | Tagged , | Leave a comment

What’s Old and New in the Midterm Philippine Elections?

Written for The Diplomat

The Philippine Commission on Elections (Comelec) says that that it has received 43,033 applications for the midterm elections scheduled for May 2025. Each voter will select 12 senators, a district representative, a partylist representative, and local officials in each province, city, and municipality. A total of 18,280 elective posts will be available for competition. The poll body said there are 183 candidates for senator and 190 partylist groups.

The week-long filing of candidacies has revealed several old and new features of the Philippine political and electoral system. Overall, they confirmed the persistence of the critique that old families continue to dominate and stunt the local political landscape. There have been efforts to introduce reforms but so far they have yet to make a substantial impact in making politics more equal and democratic. These issues are expected to be raised again in the succeeding months leading to the start of the campaign period in February.

Read more

Election Campaign Begins with Marcos-Duterte War of Words

Written for The Diplomat

The first week of the mid-term election campaign in the Philippines has been marked by a vicious exchange of words between President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and former President Rodrigo Duterte.

The challenge for the opposition is not just to expose the self-serving motives of Marcos and Duterte but to articulate the everyday economic concerns of ordinary citizens. More importantly, opposition groups should prove that they offer a better model of governance and are determined to exact accountability from erring officials.

Read more

Posted in election, nation | Tagged , | Leave a comment

The Politics of ‘Ayuda’ in the Philippines

Written for The Diplomat

Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. signed the 2025 national budget with a provision for the “conditional implementation” of some items, including a controversial “ayuda” (aid) program for the poor.

It is unfortunate that “ayuda” has earned a negative connotation when it is an emergency lifeline that could make a difference in the lives of many. Banning politicians from “ayuda” distribution is a step forward but the more crucial action is for the government to come up with a holistic approach to develop the economy to solve poverty instead of relying on cash distribution schemes.

Read more

Who Controls the Philippine Budget?

Written for The Diplomat

For Philippine Vice President Sara Duterte, two officials control the country’s budget: House of Representatives appropriations committee chair Rep. Elizaldy Co and Speaker Ferdinand Martin G. Romualdez, the first cousin of President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr.

Duterte may be stonewalling the search for the truth about whether she misappropriated public funds, but stakeholders should take advantage of the heightened attention on the budget process to demand greater transparency and accountability over how public officials and agencies deliberate, modify, approve, and spend the national budget.

Read more

Posted in nation | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Banning Joma Sison on social media sets a dangerous precedent

Published by Bulatlat

The repeated removal of Jose Maria Sison’s social media accounts is another example of the tech industry’s complicit role in enabling censorship at the behest of authoritarian regimes.

Sison is now banned on Facebook. Keywords linked to his name and the groups he founded are flagged and arbitrarily used as a basis to suspend accounts. He is constantly targeted not because he violated platform standards, but because he is designated by the Philippine government as a terrorist and dangerous enemy of the state. Silicon Valley companies may think that they are merely enforcing legitimate takedown requests, but the case of Sison is a reminder of how broad social media regulations can be used to stifle dissent.

By banning his accounts, it is implied that Sison is notoriously and flagrantly undermining internet norms. This is accompanied by state-sponsored disinformation and demonization campaigns depicting him as a criminal and anti-Filipino agitator. The malicious intent is to obscure Sison’s identity as a revolutionary propagandist.

For those who know him and his enduring legacy in shaping the country’s modern political history, the coordinated campaign to restrict and erase his online presence is tantamount to suppressing his political beliefs.

Sison is a prolific writer who understands the power of media and the written word to arouse, organize, and mobilize the masses. He is among the ardent followers of the late great statesman Claro M. Recto who exhorted the people, especially the youth, to lead a “second propaganda movement” in order to fight injustice and inequality in society. As an activist and revolutionary for more than half a century, Sison embodied what it means to articulate the message of the revolution through his writings elucidating his sharp grasp of politics and the need to struggle for national democracy. Detention and exile did not stop him from publishing dozens of books and sharing his radical ideas with fellow Filipinos and those who wanted to learn more about revolutionary theory and practice.

His senior years coincided with the commercialization and popularization of internet technology. His online articles reached a larger audience, especially during crisis moments when readers wanted a better and more comprehensive understanding of monopoly capitalism, socialism, and geopolitical dynamics in the world. As social media usage became more widespread, the media-savvy Sison signed up and actively engaged with internet users.

However, his followers also included spies and rabid anti-communist agents of the security cluster. They represent the paranoid state which could not tolerate Sison’s virtual activities. They stalked Sison’s accounts, unleashed an army of trolls inciting violence, and exploited vague social media rules to force the systematic expulsion of the online profiles of revolutionaries and revolutionary groups, including the pages of Sison.

Even in the supposed free market of ideas, Sison’s right to express his views and analyze the state of affairs is nullified because of his radical political standpoint. His papers on the revolutionary movement are presented as evidence that he is directly in control of the New People’s Army despite his obvious distance from the Philippines. Either tech companies are gullible or they genuinely believe that the Europe-based, 83-year-old Sison is capable of supervising an army clandestinely operating in the remote corners of the Philippine archipelago.

Indeed, Sison has other options to monitor the news and he can devise other ingenious ways to communicate with friends, comrades, and supporters. He survived more brutal forms of censorship in the past and he can certainly overcome this latest attempt to gag him online. But it does not make the social media ban less insidious. He has every right to protest the removal of his accounts and expose the digital despots behind this repressive action.

It is alarming that a lifelong activist and prominent public figure can be instantly removed from social networks as tech companies blindly adhere to what authorities are ordering them to do. The cyberspace is disturbingly turning into a space where only the narratives approved by the state are allowed to proliferate.

One does not need to subscribe to Sison’s political doctrines to see the ban as an act of censorship. If not challenged, the ban can be expanded and used as a tactic to enforce digital crackdowns. It gives tyrants the license to dictate who or what can be accessed or streamed on our networks. It is therefore a threat to our civic space.

We need to recalibrate AI tools and prevent them from being weaponized against activists, dissenters, and human rights defenders. We can learn from the ‘AI’ (Anti-Imperialist) legacy of Sison by working with digital rights advocates in and out of the country to counter tech-enabled dictatorships.

Posted in media, reds | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Resign Duterte

Published by Bayan Metro Manila

President Rodrigo Duterte is nowhere to be found amid the surging COVID-19 cases and the build-up of Chinese vessels in the West Philippine Sea.

The public health crisis alone warrants not just his attention but visible leadership to assure Filipinos that he is on top of the situation and that the government is doubling efforts to improve the pandemic response. Instead, we got photos of Duterte playing golf and jogging in the Palace grounds.

We remember when Duterte decided to give an unscheduled televised address in 2020 after he saw a news report of a protest by urban poor groups in Quezon City, and threatened to shoot those who will use violence during the crisis. Surely, the sight of hospitals reaching full capacity and people dying without receiving medical treatment should be enough to prod the president to address his terrified constituents.

This is the time for the president known for throwing expletives to use his notorious gift of gab against China’s incursion into our maritime territories.

But Duterte could not be bothered to show up and deliver a message during a crisis situation. Is he still in charge? If he is unable to discharge his duties effectively, he should step down already.

Duterte’s resignation will not solve all our problems but allowing him to remain in office will prolong our suffering. His removal as president will give us a better chance to survive the pandemic after a year of relying on lockdowns, curfew, and other militarized restrictions.

Duterte has to be made accountable for his government’s criminal negligence and human rights abuses. Some would argue that this can be done in next year’s election by rejecting Duterte’s anointed candidate. But why wait for another year when exacting accountability today would save more lives?

Donald Trump was impeached in the Lower House days before the end of his term but it was not seen as a futile exercise because it delivered a forceful statement reflecting the sentiment of those demanding accountability.

This should be our attitude too in calling for Duterte’s resignation. It should serve as a warning to all elected officials that bad governance, treason, and tyranny will force them out of power.

Posted in Bayan | Tagged , | Leave a comment

IFEX Asia brief: April, May, June 2024

April 2024. Journalists who ‘crossed the line’, digital repression, blasphemy prosecutions, and marriage equality bill. India goes to the polls amid continuing media harassment and content blocking. China’s repressive model of media and internet governance is increasingly being imposed in the region. A worsening rise in blasphemy prosecutions in Pakistan. Good news: Thailand parliament passes Marriage Equality Bill and Indonesian court strikes down articles on defamation and “fake news”. Read more.

May 2024. Pakistan’s impunity, India’s AI, PNG’s ‘media control policy’, and a landmark ruling against red-tagging in the Philippines. Media-related killings and attacks intensify in Pakistan, AI threatens elections and democracy in India, Indonesia plans to restrict investigative journalism, a landmark ruling on red-tagging in the Philippines, and Pacific groups underscore the importance of having a free press in protecting the environment. Read more.

June 2024. VPN ban, visa weaponisation, banned apps, and censorship across Asia. Once again, censorship and arrests marked the anniversary of the “Tiananmen Massacre” in Hong Kong. Governments across the region have imposed repressive policies such as a VPN ban, blocking of apps, red-tagging, social media licensing, and denial of visas to critical journalists. Read more.

Posted in east asia, media | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Sara Duterte Decries ‘Political Harassment’ Against Her Family

Written for The Diplomat

Philippines Vice President Sara Duterte has described the decision to remove 75 police personnel from her security detail as “political harassment.”

“Let us spare our people from all the lies. Let us call it what it is – a clear case of political harassment,” Duterte said in her four-page open letter addressed to the country’s police chief. She added that it was a “targeted maneuver” since the reassigned cops were mostly from Davao City where she previously served as mayor.

This latest spat between the vice president, the police, and administration allies reflects the widening rift between the Duterte and Marcos political dynasties which initially formed a unity team during the 2022 election. The tension could get worse since the Marcos government has shifted its stance on the work of the International Criminal Court which is currently prosecuting former President Rodrigo Duterte and some of his subordinates regarding their role in the bloody “war on drugs.”

Read more

Legislators Defer Approval of Vice President’s Budget

Written for The Diplomat

A committee of the Philippine House of Representatives deferred the approval of the 2025 budget of Vice President Sara Duterte, reflecting not just the worsening rift between erstwhile allied political clans but also the clamor for more transparent and prudent spending of public funds.

In 2022 and 2023, the budget of Duterte’s office was quickly approved by legislators as part of the parliamentary courtesy provided to the country’s second-highest official. But this didn’t happen this year, not only because the Dutertes have openly called for the resignation of President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr., but also because Vice President Duterte refused to properly answer the questions of legislators during the budget hearing.

The deferment of Duterte’s budget indicated her diminished support base in the House of Representatives. She is scheduled to appear again on September 10 but the budget of her office could face substantial cuts if she continues to ignore questions from legislators. She should also face the prospect of being impeached as more information is released about how she really spent her confidential funds in 2022.

Read more

Posted in nation | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Midterm Elections and the Prospect of Impeachment in the Philippines

Written for The Diplomat

Election season has officially begun in the Philippines, with the filing of candidacies of prospective candidates for the midterm polls scheduled for May 2025. But aside from election-related activities, the prospect that Vice President Sara Duterte could face impeachment is expected to dominate the local news and political scene until the end of the year.

The elections and impeachment reflect the worsening rift between two factions in the ruling coalition, led by the Marcos and Duterte clans. This became evident when the senatorial slate of President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. did not include incumbent senators who are known to be close allies of his predecessor, Rodrigo Duterte.

Impeachment is seriously being considered a year after the Dutertes openly started attacking the Marcos government. It is visibly the result of their maneuver for political dominance. However, the demand for accountability has also been a consistent clamor of various stakeholders. The discussion over impeachment should serve as a lesson and a warning to both Duterte and Marcos camps and their allies that being elected to power does not give them the mandate to commit misconduct and betray public trust.

Read more

Sara Duterte Threatened With Impeachment Over Fund Misuse

Written for The Diplomat

For the first time in Philippine history, the budget of the office of the vice president was deferred twice by a committee of the House of Representatives. Vice President Sara Duterte’s refusal to answer queries from legislators led to the deferral of her proposed budget for 2025. When she skipped the rescheduled hearing, her budget was again not approved and transmitted to the plenary with a substantial reduction.

If she continues to evade questions from Congress, she could face impeachment.

In the past two decades, legislators in the Philippines have endorsed impeachment petitions against presidents and Supreme Court chief justices. As Duterte continues to dismiss demands for transparency and accountability, she could soon become the first vice president to face an impeachment trial.

Read more

Posted in nation | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

IFEX Asia briefs: January, February, March 2024

What’s new and old in 2024: Repressive laws, attacks, and election disinformation in Asia. New media laws in India, Sri Lanka, and Nepal could negatively impact access to information. Afghanistan’s media situation remains precarious amid intensified state-backed attacks. Filmmakers in Myanmar and Malaysia face criminal charges. As political forces resort to restrictions and disinformation in Pakistan, media groups have initiated innovative ways to defend the people’s right to information. Read more

Dangers of Hong Kong’s new legislation, Indian protests blocked, and Pakistan’s post-election uncertainties. Internet shutdowns in Pakistan and India, new security legislation in Hong Kong, media impunity in Indonesia, China Dissent Monitor, and recommendations for the Malaysian Media Council. Read more

Elections-related censorship, repression, and women speak out against impunity. India’s coming election is undermined by online censorship and attacks against critics, Hong Kong’s Beijing-style security law takes effect, Vietnam arrests three prominent bloggers, and families demand justice as they speak out against impunity in the Philippines, Sri Lanka, and Thailand. Read more.

Posted in east asia, media | Tagged | Leave a comment