Political Dynasties Dominate Philippines Election — Again

Written for The Diplomat

The election victory of Ferdinand Marcos Jr. in this month’s Philippine presidential election reflected the continuing dominance of political dynasties in the country’s political life.

The return of the Marcoses has reminded many about the dangers of a single family monopolizing political power. The social problems engendered by the dominance of political dynasties certainly did not begin with the rise of the Marcoses nor did they disappear after the family was deposed in 1986. Politics over the past three decades has continued to be infected with cronyism, patronage, violence, corruption, and elitism, which have led to mass cynicism and dissatisfaction. That the next president is another Marcos highlights the tragedy and paradox of modern Philippine politics. It is tragic because no substantial accountability has been pursued against those who benefited from placing the country under dictatorship; and unreal because we are so outraged by what’s happening in the country yet we feel the political system is designed in a way that would only allow dynasties to remain in power

Read more

No Honeymoon for the Marcos Presidency?

Written for The Diplomat

The Commission on Elections (Comelec) has junked several cases seeking the disqualification of former Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr., which could pave the way for his proclamation as the next president of the Philippines after garnering a sizeable lead in this week’s presidential election.

Marcos ran on a platform of building unity in the country. Can he convince those who suffered during the Martial Law years to unite with him even if he continues to deny that atrocities were committed in the past? Is unity possible between Marcoses and other political forces which wanted to reclaim the ill-gotten wealth of the family? What kind of unity will Marcos promote if the demands for truth, justice, and accountability are addressed to his own family?

It is too early for Marcos to celebrate because even if the voting has ended, the political opposition is not eager to surrender the fight for what they think is right and just for the nation’s future.

Read more

Posted in election, nation | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Duterte’s deadly legacy

Published by the Philippine Daily Inquirer

The specter of unabated killings is the brutal legacy of the Duterte administration.

President Duterte waged a bloody war on drugs that led to thousands of killings. Most of the victims are suspected petty drug users, peddlers, and barangay bystanders. The police went on a deadly “tokhang” rampage but failed to end the drug menace.

Mr. Duterte relentlessly attacked activists, leftists, opposition leaders, and critics. Many of them became victims of extrajudicial killings. These include lawyers, environmentalists, indigenous peoples, farmers, reporters, local officials, peace consultants, and human rights defenders.

We believe these are state-sponsored killings that Mr. Duterte enabled through official and unofficial policies and declarations. From “tokhang” directives to martial law in Mindanao and the imposition of a state of lawlessness in Negros and Samar islands, the Duterte administration weaponized the bureaucracy, which led to fatal consequences. It has to be made accountable for legitimizing the attacks against urban poor residents, activists, and rural communities.

Mr. Duterte’s anticommunist rhetoric demonized the work of activists. He criminalized activism by linking the advocacies of people’s organizations with armed struggle. Suspected communist sympathizers are harassed, red-tagged, charged with trumped-up cases, and targeted by death squads.

In 2020, Mr. Duterte’s bungled COVID-19 response led to several unnecessary deaths. His criminal neglect has worsened the suffering of the people. His militarist and harsh lockdown restrictions have curtailed the rights of workers. Official COVID-19 monitoring does not count the number of people who died because of lockdown impositions, the overkill deployment of troops in communities, and those who were deprived of hospital health care.

We remember the victims of “tokhang.” We honor the lives of activists who were killed for bringing light to this world. We mourn those who died this year because of government incompetence and repression. The struggle continues until we achieve justice.

Posted in Bayan, nation | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Muog na Buo: Song of the resistance

Published by Bulatlat

The Philippine revolution has long baffled political scientists. It emerged in an archipelago dominated by an imperialist power and thrived even after the disintegration of the communist bloc. There’s no socialist rear offering refuge to armed revolutionaries. There’s no industrial base where Soviet-style insurrections can immediately take place. There are only islands in this part of the Pacific Ring of Fire dotted with active volcanoes and faultlines. Yet, a Maoist-inspired revolution is being waged here in the past half-century. A fluke of history? Not if we link it to the country’s anti-colonial struggle. From local revolts spanning 80 years to establishing Asia’s first republic, Filipino islanders have persisted in resisting colonial bondage. They proved how political revolution would prevail over the divide-and-rule strategy of the colonizers which gave birth to the Philippine nation. It was an epic struggle that united the islands amid fierce and bitter divisions among Christians, Muslims, and ethnic communities. But imperialism became the new plague after the demise of colonialism, and the nation was relegated into a neocolony. It meant the pursuit of nation-building under the tutelage of a foreign power. The islands were targeted (read: plundered) for their precious resources but wealth was hoarded somewhere else. This legitimized dispossession was challenged by the resurgence of the national liberation movement. Those who profit from the exploitation of our lands are the most rabid in demonizing the people’s resistance. They spread the self-serving lie that revolutions would only doom our future. But against the expectations of the conservative establishment, the struggle has lasted up to this day. It was supposed to be dead or dying yet it kept on appearing as a specter haunting the elite.

The song ‘Muog na Buo’ alludes to the specific character of the struggle for national democracy in the Philippines. It highlights the aim of revolutionaries to turn the scattered isles (kalat-kalat na pulo) into a solid fortress (muog na buo). It is a reminder that the Maoist doctrine of protracted war from the countryside to the cities cannot be dogmatically applied to the Philippines which has a different history, political landscape, and geographical terrain. It is a celebration of the creativity and tenacity of Filipino revolutionaries who have enriched the Marxist theory of struggle in an archipelagic setting. It validates the enduring legacy of our anti-colonial heroes who sought to unite the nation by waging a war for independence. This is how the unfinished revolution will hasten the arrival of a new political future:

Narito tayo para sa pagkakaisa, pagsulong
Narito tayo para sa masang aping Pilipino
Narito tayo para ang kalat-kalat na pulo
Magiging muog na buo

We are here for unity, forward advance
We are here for the oppressed Filipino masses
We are here to turn our scattered isles
Into a solid fortress

Then and now, it is through political struggle that our people were able to overcome our isolation from each other in order to build a common stand against local and foreign oppressors. Solidarity countered the destructive effect of divisive politics. Centuries of promoting a type of island mentality that pits natives against each other made it more difficult for progressive forces to introduce a new type of politics. Hence, the need for a continuing cultural revolution to fight old values and habits with an empowering outlook in life and politics.

Again, the song ‘Muog na Buo’ speaks about the experience of many activists grappling with the contradictions brought about by their world-building praxis. At first, it mentions the individual engaged in political struggle guided by revolutionary theory. Later, the individual who believes he or she is changing the world (Narito ako / I am here) proclaims the necessity of collective struggle (Narito tayo / We are here). This is not an abrupt transformation but an arduous struggle which only confirms that genuinely embracing revolutionary politics will significantly change the self. It is not an aimless journey of an enlightened individual to some utopian destination but a basic political undertaking that features painstaking grassroots organizing, creative application of theory and tactics, building community power, and reframing everyday politics into a platform that can allow ordinary citizens to link arms with both kasamas and strangers to seize the day and win a new future.

Like the foolish old man who wanted to remove a mountain in the Chinese fable, there are also stubborn Filipino islanders who believe they can turn the 7,600 islands into a solid rock.

*The lyrics of the song Muog na Buo was penned by Silvia Madiaga

Posted in reds | Leave a comment

Introducing the Colors of the Philippine Election

Written for The Diplomat

Candidates in the ongoing Philippine presidential campaign have relied on certain colors as part of their political branding. By choosing a particular color, candidates aim to unify supporters and mobilize them to reach out to more voters. Their success or popularity in the campaign trail is made more visible through the colors they have chosen.

It is expected that these colors will continue to compete for dominance ahead of the elections scheduled for May 9. These colors are useful for candidates and they make the campaign activities more visually attractive, but they can be a disservice to voters who may think that a color is an adequate substitute for the type of campaigning that promotes political parties, their platforms, and the track record of their leaders.

Read more

How Long Will Rodrigo Duterte Remain Neutral in the Philippine Election?

Written for The Diplomat

During a recent provincial election rally, Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte reiterated his decision about not endorsing any presidential candidate, despite several hints that he is poised to anoint former Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr. as his successor. Duterte has endorsed the local and senatorial candidates of his party but he stopped short of naming his choice for president by claiming that he is neutral.

Duterte could be simply being coy but it is more likely that he is just biding his time and waiting for the right political moment before making an announcement. As a cunning veteran politician, Duterte is known for making contradictory statements intended to confuse the public, especially his rivals. This is evident not just in his remarks but also in the actions of his subordinates.

Read more

Posted in election | Tagged , | Leave a comment

IFEX Asia Regional Briefs: July, August, September 2021

July 2021: #FOEwatch in Malaysia, Hong Kong freedom in ‘tatters’, Kem Ley, and arrests in Vietnam. Artists and activists summoned by Malaysian police, the continuing fight for justice five years after Kem Ley’s death in Cambodia, Hong Kong media freedom in ‘tatters’, alarming arrests and convictions in Vietnam, released journalists share their prison ordeal in Myanmar, and Pegasus spyware in India. Read more

August 2021: Protecting journalists in Afghanistan, #Lawan protest in Malaysia, and shrinking civic space in Hong Kong. Groups called for the protection of journalists and citizens at risk in Afghanistan, participants of #Lawan protests were summoned by the police in Malaysia, threats forced Hong Kong’s largest teachers’ union and pro-democracy coalition to disband, regulations against disinformation were introduced in Thailand and South Korea, and women journalists Rozina Islam, Maria Ressa, and Cheng Lei remained defiant despite facing persecution. Read more

September 2021: Attacks against alternative media, #FreeZhangZhan, and historic RTI victory in Sri Lanka. Two alternative media websites were targeted by cyberattacks in the Philippines, while an independent news website was forced to stop operating in Singapore. Human rights groups call for the humanitarian release of lawyer and journalist Zhang Zhan in China. A landmark court ruling in Sri Lanka led to the disqualification of an official based on evidence obtained through the Right to Information Act. Read more

Posted in east asia, media | Tagged | Leave a comment

Duterte, Duque, and the IATF generals

Published by Bayan Metro Manila

As health workers press for a two-week timeout, we assert that it’s time to go for Duque, IATF generals, and even President Rodrigo Duterte.

We share the observation that the government’s COVID-19 response has been largely ineffective in containing the spread of the virus. We blame the inept leadership of Duque, the IATF dominated by retired generals, and Duterte.

Duterte’s militaristic approach has only led to economic woes, displacement, and human rights abuses.

Our alarming situation today is the result of the reluctance to conduct mass testing, the failure to enhance the country’s healthcare capacity, and the absence of a comprehensive medical solution to the pandemic. This reflects a leadership bereft of vision and empathy for ordinary citizens.

Duterte was quick to ask for emergency powers to realign public funds and secure loans but his government has been criminally negligent in extending assistance to the needy.

Nasaan ang ayuda? Nasaan ang plano?

His government imposed repressive lockdown measures without enforcing a holistic program in dealing with the harsh impact of the pandemic. Instead, he relied on the police and military to lead the government’s response instead of mobilizing health experts. He focused on silencing the media and passing the draconian Terror Law instead of prioritizing how his government will attend to the social welfare needs of the people.

We caution against the return to the Duterte-style ECQ which only worsened the suffering of many. We remember how hard lockdowns saw the heavy deployment of troops in communities but failed to reverse the surging number of COVID-19 cases.

We need a new approach guided by scientific thinking, transparent governance, and democratic principles. This paradigm is the exact opposite of what Duterte and his generals at the IATF are doing. At the minimum, the IATF needs to be revamped. Duterte’s handling of the crisis is also an ominous indicator of his capability to lead in the next two years.

In other words, if Duterte is unable to lead the country, and as he continues to spew out dangerous suggestions to the public (gasoline as disinfectant), it is only proper that we call for a new leadership. Duterte said in his recent Sona: ‘Buhay muna bago ang lahat’. We agree. To save Filipino lives and in order for us to survive the pandemic, it’s time for Duterte to go.

Posted in Bayan, health, nation | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The Philippine Government’s Distrust of Fact-Checkers

Published by The Diplomat

The Philippines’ Office of the Solicitor General has threatened to file a case in the court if the Commission on Elections (Comelec) does not unilaterally revoke its Memorandum of Agreement with news website Rappler on pursuing voter awareness and fact-checking campaigns ahead of the national and local elections scheduled for May 9. Meanwhile, the government’s anti-communist task force said it plans to file charges against Rappler over an article that fact-checked the agency’s statement against Leftist legislators.

Read more

The Hypocrisy of President Duterte’s UN Speech

Published by The Diplomat

On September 22, Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte addressed the United Nations General Assembly during its 76th session as a leader condemning global injustice while committing himself to pursue governance reforms.

He talked mainly about the hoarding of vaccines by rich nations, the lack of concrete and sustained action to address the climate crisis, the danger of foreign interference in countries dealing with “complex problems,” and the obsolete mechanisms of the U.N.

Duterte might have appeared convincing at first because he was right on the mark in calling out the actions of rich countries that have led to the alarming disparity of vaccine distribution in the world. He was also correct in highlighting the accountability of developed nations in the slow rollout of reforms that will supposedly reduce their carbon emissions.

But for those who are familiar with what has happened in the Philippines over the past five years, Duterte’s U.N. speech sounded comical, if not tragic, due to the failure of the Filipino leader to “walk his talk.”

Read more

Posted in media, nation | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Resilience and resistance in the Philippines

Published by Bulatlat

Authorities often downplay the traumatic impact of disasters by celebrating the resilience of their constituents. They highlight the bravery of survivors, the will to overcome unending tragedies, and the instinct to find humor and hope in the face of adversity. However, not all have sincere motives. There are those who simply wanted to evade accountability and hide their misdeeds by praising the resilience of the local population. Their sinister intent is obscured by similar narratives that emphasize the importance of mastering the vicissitudes of life. Hence, the powerful meaning of resilience is downgraded. From being a code of hope and endurance, it became a bureaucratic jargon used by politicians for petty politicking. Even the advocates of political-correctness are hesitant to invoke it in times of disaster because it might be interpreted as an endorsement of the incompetence and criminal negligence of public officials.

But resilience is a word too special to be abandoned so that callous politicians could only appropriate it for their selfish interests. For the longest time, it refers to people overcoming odds through sheer bravery and ingenuity. Why then should we tolerate opportunists who are devaluing its meaning? Instead of refraining from using it in our social discourse, we should reclaim ownership of its radical significance. It should be deployed in our linguistic arsenal as we pursue our political work.

For example, resilience is an apt word to describe the long-running people’s resistance in the Philippines. The national democratic struggle has thrived for more than half a century during the long Cold War era, the fall and disintegration of the Soviet bloc, and the spread of neoconservatism in the world. It has endured the brutal Martial Law dictatorship, the continuous all-out-wars waged by post-Marcos regimes, and the global ideological offensive against Marxism.

Its longevity is lampooned as proof of its failure as a political force. Those who echo this line fail to realize the contradiction in their argument: a supposedly obsolete movement continues to threaten the hegemony of the ruling class. They refuse to acknowledge that the revolutionary struggle has lasted this long because it has popular support.

The 20th century saw the rise of anti-colonial revolutions in Third World societies led by nationalists and communists. Some Marxist parties came to power but the uprising in other countries was violently crushed. The Philippine struggle is linked to the unfinished revolution of 1896, the fight for independence until the end of World War II, and the Huk rebellion in the 1950s. The national democratic movement emerged in the late 1950s which helped usher the revival of nationalism in the 1960s. This became the backbone of the people’s resistance which challenged the tyranny of Marcos in the 1970s and 1980s.

Succeeding administrations touted the country’s political and economic transition to dismiss the revolutionary aims of the national democratic movement. But three decades later, the Philippine state is still beleaguered by systemic ills that led to social uprisings in the past. Meanwhile, the national democratic Left continues not just to offer its program as a viable alternative but remains persistent in its comprehensive struggle for social transformation.

The country’s reactionary class has an uninterrupted rule but conveniently blames the Left for the social problems afflicting the nation. Even more absurd is that it pokes fun at the supposed failure of the armed Left to occupy and govern a territory in the islands. It could not make up its mind whether both the underground and legal Left are too powerful to dictate the country’s political economy or too insignificant and weak to dominate local politics. It knows only the language of violence when describing its class enemy. Hence, its desperation to defeat the Left is revealed by its obsession to demean the national democratic movement by branding it as dogmatic, dictatorial, unchristian, and anti-Filipino.

Despite the state-sponsored aggression against the Left and the anti-Left bashing in mainstream institutions, the flags of the national democratic movement are still waving high and even resurgent in some places.

After more than half a century, the Philippine revolutionary struggle could already offer its experience in conducting a protracted resistance in this part of the world. It could serve as a model for building a self-reliant movement while battling both fascists and revisionists. There are important lessons from other countries that can guide us in probing the status of our struggle, and at the same time, we can already put forward our own history to enrich the theory and practice of political revolution.

State reprisals have so far failed to stop the advance of the people’s movement. The heirs of Dagohoy, Bonifacio and Gabriela Silang are demonstrating how revolutionaries are capable of enduring decades of hardship and sacrifice without surrendering the fight for real independence and democracy. Some are braving the frontlines of dissent while others are finding other creative ways to support the resistance. Some are fleeing from intensified crackdowns and retreating to other places where political organizing is more feasible. This resiliency is what makes the revolutionary struggle in the Philippines a solid rock of refuge in the raging waters of tyranny and state terror.

Posted in reds | Tagged | Leave a comment

Senators suppressing free speech

Published by Bayan Metro Manila

As Terror Law takes effect, senators are setting a dangerous precedent in suppressing free speech

Bong Go filing a case against a student for sharing ‘libelous’ posts on social media. Ping Lacson accusing critics of the Terror Law of spreading disinformation. And Senate President Tito Sotto prioritizing the passage of a bill criminalizing ‘fake news’.

Senators are on a rampage in suppressing free speech on the eve of the enforcement of the draconian Terror Law.

After the rejection of the ABS-CBN franchise, Bato dela Rosa advised employees of the TV and radio broadcaster to look for other jobs, which not only smacks of insensitivity but also proved his failure to see the Congress decision as an attack on press freedom.

Sotto’s announcement that his proposed Anti-False Content Act (SBN 9) is among his priority bills is worrisome. Criminalizing ‘fake news’ will undermine free expression. We saw how the anti-fake news provision in the Bayanihan Law was used to run after critics of the government’s handling of the COVID-19 crisis.

We fear that Sotto’s bill, if passed into law, will be misused and abused by politicians to silence legitimate criticism.

Look how Bong Go used his position to appeal for NBI’s help in chasing after social media critics. Bong Go’s press statement claimed that he was only trying to stop the sharing of ‘fake news’ content. This is problematic since authorities can arbitrarily designate any comment as ‘fake news’ and use existing repressive laws and Sotto’s law in the future to charge ordinary netizens and create a chilling effect in society.

Lacson arrogantly dismissed critics of the Terror Law and accused the opposition of spreading disinformation. He not only insulted the intelligence of the vigilant public but also demonstrated how politicians like him are unwilling to listen to contrary views.

It seems many senators are infected with the virus of intolerance because they continue to be remorseless in enacting repressive laws like the Terror Law. Sotto’s bill will be another instrument that can be weaponized by paranoid politicians to punish citizens demanding accountability from the government.

Our advice to Sotto: Counter fake news with accurate information. Promote media literacy, instead of penalizing internet users.

To Bong Go, focus on legislation instead of being vindictive to social media users.

To Lacson, stop peddling lies about the content and intent of the Terror Law.

If these senators really want to make online discourse safe and productive, they should mainly address the lack of reliable internet access and the failure to put forward policies guaranteeing internet rights.

Posted in Bayan | Tagged | Leave a comment

The books I read in 2021

Published by Bulatlat

1. UP Diliman: Home and Campus by Narita Manuel Gonzales (Editor), Gerardo Los Banos (Editor). Remembering the early years of the churches in Diliman, tribute to Father Delaney, and the lives of pioneer residents in the campus.

2. China’s Long Revolution by Edgar Snow. Documenting the changes a few years after China’s cultural revolution. It features interviews with Chinese leaders Chou Enlai and Mao Zedong.

3. Black Holes and Baby Universes and Other Essays by Stephen Hawking. A fascinating collection of speeches, lectures, and interviews featuring the life and work of a renowned scientist. Is time travel possible? What was Einstein’s biggest mistake? Can we come out of a black hole?

4. Beyond the Spectacle of Terrorism by Henry A. Giroux. Linking the role of new media, spectacle and politics of terrorism, and ends with a hopeful assertion of emancipatory pedagogy. I like the concept of public time as a counter to the nihilistic legacy of neoliberalism.

5. A History of the Philippines by Samuel K. Tan. Useful introduction of how our communities evolved, the interaction with colonizers, the fight for independence and democracy – only to falter in the end for its partisan support of the Ramos presidency.

6. Hong Kong Junta by S.V. Epistola. Narrating the activities of the Philippine revolutionary government in exile, the independence lobbying efforts from Japan to Paris, and how the U.S. government behaved before turning the Philippines into its colony.

7. Philippines-Mexico Historical Relations, Ambeth R. Ocampo (Editor). Lectures and papers detailing the historical and cultural ties between the Philippines and Mexico. For 250 years, Spain ruled the Philippines through Mexico which was facilitated by the Manila-Acapulco galleon trade.

8. The Silk Roads: A New History of the World by Peter Frankopan. Refreshing, intelligent frame in understanding the history of the world. Manila was described here as the first global city. Compelling narratives about the rise and fall of kingdoms and their forgotten legacies.

9. Hindi Nangyari Dahil Wala sa Social Media: Interogasyon ng Kulturang New Media sa Pilipinas by Rolando B. Tolentino (Editor), Vladimeir B. Gonzales (Editor), Laurence Marvin S. Castillo (Editor). An important new book about our media landscape and its impact on the lives of Filipinos in the early 21st century. Read my previous Bulatlat column for a full review of the book.

10 Intimations by Zadie Smith. Impressions, observations, tender reflections about life, modern life in the age of pandemic.

11. The Silence by Don DeLillo. A curious take on a probable futuristic scenario when our technologies suddenly die on us.

12. How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy by Jenny Odell. My favorite book of the year by a Filipino-American artist and scholar about how and why we should recalibrate our thinking and habits in our use of new media tools. What is the link between birdwatching and improving our internet literacy? Her philosophy is progressive, humane, and maybe that Filipino connection made her more sensitive about nature, myths, and the interaction of strangers in communities.

13. Convenience Store Woman by Sayaka Murata, Ginny Tapley Takemori (Translator). An equally hilarious and depressing story about life and work in a neoliberal world.

14. The Interrogative Mood by Padgett Powell. Questions, only questions, but full of meaning and answers about what it means to live today.

15. Ang Huling Emotero by Mark Angeles. It starts with a brief history of dagli in the past century, then it offers tales about our ancestors, sketches inspired by real-life events, stories about us.

16. The Lessons of History by Will Durant, Ariel Durant. Confident in its sweeping review of history, but careful in reminding readers not to make a final judgment of what has transpired in the past. Apparently, there were many ‘socialisms’ in various civilizations.

17. Salvation: Black People and Love by bell hooks. Explores the dynamics of authentic liberation while battling white supremacy in modern America.

Posted in education | Tagged | Leave a comment